Definition: Rollback taxes are extra property taxes owed when a property’s use changes and it no longer qualifies for previously granted tax exemptions or breaks. These taxes apply retroactively, requiring the landowner to pay the difference between the property tax rates they previously benefited from and the standard rates over a set number of past years.
When Rollback Taxes Apply
Rollback taxes commonly occur in the following situations:
Change in land use:
If agricultural or open-space land receiving a special tax benefit is converted to residential or commercial use, the owner may owe rollback taxes due to the difference between tax rates based on land use classifications.
Loss of exemption:
Rollback taxes may be assessed if a property previously receiving an exemption (such as a homestead or conservation exemption) is sold or used for a non-qualifying use.
Failure to meet assessment requirements:
Rollback taxes may be triggered if a property fails to meet the minimum requirements for a tax reduction program, such as farmland assessment requirements or compliance with farmland assessment regulations.
Incomplete applications or ineligible land:
A property owner who submits an incomplete application or fails to file a separate application for a tax exemption may later be required to pay rollback taxes.
How Rollback Taxes Are Calculated
Rollback taxes are typically calculated based on the difference between the lower assessed tax rate and the standard rate, including any prior exemptions, over a period of time. The calculation considers factors such as:
Fair market value vs. special appraisal: If a property was previously assessed under a special appraisal method (e.g., for agricultural use), the valuation standard will shift to actual assessment at fair market value.
Additional assessment: The property owner must pay the difference between the previously reduced assessment and the new, higher assessment.
Future taxes and delinquent taxes: In some cases, failure to pay rollback taxes can result in delinquent taxes, leading to penalties or interest charges.
Example Calculation
A landowner has agricultural land that was taxed based on a special farmland assessment for five years. The tax rate under the special appraisal was 1.5%, while the standard tax rate for all commercial properties is 2.5%. Upon converting the land for commercial development, rollback taxes are assessed for the past five years:
Year 1: (2.5% – 1.5%) × $500,000 = $5,000
Year 2: (2.5% – 1.5%) × $520,000 = $5,200
Year 3: (2.5% – 1.5%) × $540,000 = $5,400
Year 4: (2.5% – 1.5%) × $560,000 = $5,600
Year 5: (2.5% – 1.5%) × $580,000 = $5,800
Total Rollback Taxes Due: $27,000 (plus potential penalties and interest)
Appealing Rollback Tax Assessments
In some cases, property owners can challenge rollback taxes. Successfully appealing a rollback tax assessment can result in significant savings, but the process requires careful preparation and an understanding of local property tax laws. Common grounds for appeal include:
Incorrect assessment:
If the actual use of the property has not changed, but rollback taxes were applied mistakenly.
Misclassification of land use:
If the local tax authority incorrectly categorized the property’s use.
Exemptions or special provisions:
Some jurisdictions allow exemptions for specific types of land conversions, such as conservation efforts.
To appeal, property owners need to take these steps:
Gather documentation proving the original land use and any continued eligibility for tax benefits.
Submit an appeal with the local tax authority within the designated timeframe.
Consult a property tax expert for the best chance of a successful appeal.
Common Mistakes That Trigger Rollback Taxes
Many property owners make simple mistakes that lead to rollback taxes. Some of the most common errors include:
Failing to understand land use requirements:
Not being aware of the specific conditions that must be met to maintain an agricultural or open-space tax status.
Neglecting to reapply for exemptions:
Many tax exemptions require periodic renewal, and failure to do so can result in unexpected tax liabilities.
Converting property without reviewing tax implications:
Developing or rezoning land without considering the rollback tax consequences.
Miscommunication with local authorities:
Changes in ownership, land use, or exemptions should be clearly reported to avoid accidental assessment errors.
Reduce Your Property Tax Burden
If you’re facing rollback taxes or want to make sure you’re maximizing your property tax savings, Ownwell can help.
On average, we save 31% more than our competitors and have an 89% success rate. We specialize in real estate tax savings, helping property owners navigate tax exemptions and appeals.