Home
/US Property Taxes
/New York
/Suffolk County
/Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York Property Taxes

  • Median Shelter Island Heights, NY effective property tax rate: 0.57%, significantly lower than the national median of 1.02%, but lower than the New York state median of 2.39%.

  • Median Shelter Island Heights, NY home value: $1,161,797

  • Median annual Shelter Island Heights, NY tax bill: $5,834, $3,434 higher than the national median property tax bill of $2,400.

How are property taxes in Suffolk calculated?

Property taxes in Shelter Island Heights, NY are calculated based on the tax assessed value, which is often lower than the actual market value due to property tax exemptions such as the homestead or senior exemption.

Understanding Shelter Island Heights’ property tax system, exemptions, and reduction opportunities can lead to significant savings. Regardless of where you live in Shelter Island Heights, knowing local tax details benefits homeowners and investors.

Last Updated March 1, 2025

Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York Property Tax Bill Calculator

$100,000

$1,500,000

$3,000,000

Median Effective Tax Rate

0.57%

Estimate Property Tax Bill

$6,622

$6,145

SAVE WITH OWNWELL

$1,102

Average Tax Savings

Ownwell’s Shelter Island Heights Property Tax Bill Calculator empowers homeowners, real estate investors, and potential buyers to estimate their annual property taxes in Shelter Island Heights with just two data points.

By entering your property's estimated assessed value, our calculator applies Shelter Island Heights’ median effective tax rate to accurately estimate your property tax bill. Note that your property's assessed value — determined by your county — reflects any exemptions you may have, ensuring a more precise calculation for your property tax obligations.

This insightful tool helps you understand potential tax liabilities and highlights how Ownwell can assist in reducing property taxes in Suffolk County.

For those interested in more localized information, please scroll down to explore city-level trends!

Property Tax Rates Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Local government entities are responsible for setting tax rates, which can vary significantly within a state. Each year, counties estimate their required budget to provide essential services and divide that by the total value of all taxable property within their jurisdiction. This calculation results in the property tax rate. While votes and laws play a role in setting these rates and budgets, this is the basic annual process. In Shelter Island Heights, located in Suffolk County, the effective property tax rate reflects these calculations. Compared to other cities in New York, Shelter Island Heights offers a unique perspective on property taxation. The locality's tax rate can be compared to both the state median and the national median, providing a clearer picture of how it stands against broader benchmarks. The national median property tax rate is 1.02%, while Shelter Island Heights' rate provides insight into the local tax landscape. Understanding these comparisons can help property owners make informed decisions about their investments and financial planning in New York.

Property Tax Rates Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Source: Ownwell

Loading...

0.16%

1.54%

2.91%

Our median effective property tax rate (tax bill ÷ assessor's market value) accounts for exemptions and deductions, making it more accurate than the general median tax rate, which is the midpoint of statutory rates before adjustments.

Median Effective Shelter Island Heights Tax Rate

0.57%

Our median effective property tax rate (tax bill ÷ assessor's market value) accounts for exemptions and deductions, making it more accurate than the general median tax rate, which is the midpoint of statutory rates before adjustments.

Median Effective Suffolk County Tax Rate

108.95%

Median Effective New York Tax Rate

2.39%

Median Effective United States Tax Rate

1.02%

Property Tax Rates Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Zip10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian Tax Rate75th Percentile90th Percentile
119650.28%0.28%0.57%0.57%0.57%

Source: Ownwell

Property Tax Assessment Values Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

When examining property taxes in Shelter Island Heights, NY, understanding the distinction between "market value" and "assessed value" is crucial. The market value is what a willing buyer would pay to a willing seller in an open and competitive market, often influenced by location, property condition, and economic market trends. The Suffolk County appraisal district estimates the market value for tax purposes. The assessed value is the market value minus any applicable exemptions or limits determined by local laws and offerings. The tax assessed value is the figure used to calculate your property taxes or the amount multiplied by your tax rate to get your tax bill.

In Suffolk County, assessment notices are sent in the spring each year. They’ll typically reach your mailbox by the middle of May. Each property owner receives an assessment notice that contains both the market value and assessed value, along with an estimate of your property tax bill. By providing insights into how assessed and market values are determined, this section helps property owners navigate their tax responsibilities and understand the valuation processes affecting their property taxes in Shelter Island Heights.

For example, the median home price in Shelter Island Heights is $1,161,797, with tax bills ranging significantly across the county. Zip code 11965 has the highest median home price at $1,161,797.

Property Tax Assessment Values Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Source: Ownwell

Loading...

$3,298

$3,252,219

$6,501,139

Median Shelter Island Heights Market Value

$1,161,797

Median Suffolk County Market Value

$6,290

Median New York Market Value

$255,644

Median United States Market Value

$235,294

Property Tax Assessment Values Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Zip10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian Home Price75th Percentile90th Percentile
11965$707,865$833,708$1,161,797$2,410,674$3,798,876

Source: Ownwell

Property Tax Bills Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Property tax bills in Shelter Island Heights, located in Suffolk County, NY, are calculated based on the assessed value of a property and the local tax rate. The assessed value is determined by the local tax assessor and is a percentage of the property's market value. In this area, the median home price is $1,161,797, which significantly influences the tax bill. Tax bills can vary widely, with the 25th percentile at $3,966 and the 75th percentile reaching $11,509. The highest median tax bill recorded in the region is $5,834, notably higher than the national median property tax bill of $2,400.

Factors such as property location, improvements, and market trends also impact the final tax bill. For homeowners, these taxes can be a substantial financial burden. Ownwell assists by reviewing your property assessment, identifying potential inaccuracies, and filing appeals to ensure you’re not overpaying. By leveraging their expertise, homeowners can potentially save significantly on their property tax bills, making homeownership more affordable and manageable.

Property Tax Bills Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Source: Ownwell

Loading...

$2,771

$10,909

$19,046

Median Shelter Island Heights Tax Bill

$5,834

Median Suffolk County Tax Bill

$10,006

Median New York Tax Bill

$5,938

Median United States Tax Bill

$2,400

Property Tax Bills Across Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, New York

Zip10th Percentile25th PercentileMedian Tax Bill75th Percentile90th Percentile
11965$2,744$3,966$5,834$11,509$17,598

Source: Ownwell

Don't miss the deadline to file a grievance!